Player-hosted DonutSMP gambling: paper games, hosts and what you can check

What a player-hosted game really is, where the edge comes from, and why a result you cannot recompute cannot be trusted.

A lot of DonutSMP gambling never touches a website. A player sets up a game in a base or at spawn, the paper game being the best known, takes your /pay and decides whether you won. Some hosts are honest and some are not, and from where you stand the two look exactly the same. This guide explains how these games usually work, where the host's edge comes from, how to work out that edge for any version, and what changes when the game runs on seeds you can check afterwards.

None of this is about any particular player. It is about the shape of the game: whoever runs it controls it, and nothing is written down before you pay.

The usual version goes like this. You pay the host, the host and you each draw or reveal a number, and the higher number wins. If you win, the host pays you back a multiple of your stake. If the numbers are equal, the host keeps the stake. That last rule is the whole business model: the game looks even, but every tie goes one way.

Hosts run their own versions. Some use more numbers, some pay a different multiple, some reroll a tie and some keep it. The rules are whatever the host says they are that day, and they can change between one round and the next.

You can work out what any version costs you with a pen. List every pair of draws, one for you and one for the host. Count the pairs you win, the pairs the host wins and the pairs that tie. Multiply the pairs you win by what a win pays you back, divide by the number of pairs, and compare that with your stake. Whatever is missing is the host's edge, and with ties going to the host it is never zero.

That sum only holds if the draws are really random. In a game you cannot inspect, the host can stack the items, swap what you see, or simply decide the result, and no amount of counting shows it.

Bigger player games often use a middleman who holds both stakes until the result. That moves the risk rather than removing it: now you have to trust the middleman as well as the host. A middleman can leave with both stakes, a host can pay a friend posing as one, and a payment sent to a name with one wrong letter is gone. None of it leaves a record you can show anybody.

On DonutSurge the game runs on the site and the money only moves through our bots: you deposit with a /pay command the site shows you, and a payout bot pays your verified Minecraft account when you withdraw. Before every bet you see a hash of the server seed, you choose your own client seed, and the result comes from both. Afterwards you can reveal the seed and recompute the round yourself, so a result that was changed would not match.

The payout is on the key before you press it, and the edge is shown on the game page, so there is no rule that appears only after you lose. Dice and Coinflip are the closest to a paper game: Dice is you against a number you set, and Coinflip is you against another player or the bot, each side picked before the flip.

Gamble only what you would be fine losing, and stop when it stops being fun. Never send a stake to someone who reached out to you first, never pay a middleman you cannot see on the server, and keep screenshots of every payment. If a game's rules change after you have paid, walk away.

Is the DonutSMP paper game rigged?

Not always, but you cannot tell. The host keeps the ties, which gives every version an edge, and nothing is published before you pay, so an honest host and a rigged one look the same from your side.

How do I work out a paper game's odds?

List every pair of draws for you and the host, count the pairs you win, multiply by what a win pays, and divide by the number of pairs. Whatever is short of your stake is the host's edge.

Is a middleman safe for big player games?

A middleman holds both stakes, so you are trusting one more person. They can leave with both, and nothing records the result. Only use one you can see on the server and keep screenshots.

How is a game on DonutSurge different?

The result comes from a server seed whose hash you see before you bet and a client seed you choose, and you can recompute any round on the verifier. The payout is shown before you press the key, and payouts go to your verified account.